Reptillian, Kitty, Veggie, several people eating popcorn while waiting for a flame war to crop up, quit being cunts.
Kitty, I hate bishounen more than most folks, but at the end of the day, telling him what to like isn't going to make him stop liking it, or stop writing about it. And I think this sort of thing has gone on for long enough to stamp out any doubts as to whether or not this is true. You've made your criticisms candidly and with plenty of backup. Not much more can be said without an unnecessary backlash.
Reptillian, it's alright. Nothing special, but if I were you, instead of posting threads for new characters and letting people judge them. how about writing an actual story for them and letting people make their judgments after seeing them in action. It's SO much more rewarding.
I would also recommend checking out TVtropes. I find it gives me a better and ultimately very useful grasp of fiction and helps me figure out precisely what I want from a story.
Veggie...................................... who are you again?
_________________
"Also I agree with Gregole. He's always right."