MLP is all over this site. What if MLP crossed with Felarya?

What if MLP did cross with Flearya?

Either ponies get eaten or people stop eating each other. Either way NOT GOOD.

I agree with Fish, I really don't think the two universe can mix very well with each others ^^;

Crossovers in general never end up good. The most obvious problem is that people pick settings that are completely incompatible and have next to no similarities between each other.

They can mix all they want but I'm confident Felarya would devour My Little Pony like Augustus Gloop devours Wonka Bars.

Err... no. Even if some crossovers can mix very different settings, the differences between Felarya and the cotton-candy ponies are so big that it would be of such bad taste.

Fluttershy drinks her juicebox and all the preds go "HNNNNNNG" and get heart attacks

Though it could be fun seeing some giant ponies eat people up, don't you agree? ^_^

Nyaha wrote:

Though it could be fun seeing some giant ponies eat people up, don't you agree? ^_^

Horses are giant ponies, aren't they? Oh, wait, you mean THAT giant... well, we have echydins. Paint one lavender and you got your own man-eating Twilight Sparkle. xD

That question is a pandorean box that should never be opened.

Spoiler:

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

=O

Ok so... Pendragon has a f'ed up mind.. I wasn't asking for a comeplete genetic mix-up XD. Fish..... That is demented... PONIES GETTING EATEN?? Wow >.> But as I was going to say, I meant like the ponies being all giant and stuff It shows that Nyaha has the right idea here Yay for him! Okay, Which pony would be most destructive to the people, Felarya, and pretty much anything else?

I believe de proper answer for your question is: NO! Combining ponies with Felayra would be like mixing jelly with cement: Never good to mix together.

Mmmhmhmhmh~ Jelly cement. *licks lips hungrily*

Nyaha wrote:

Mmmhmhmhmh~ Jelly cement. *licks lips hungrily*

It's bad for your teeth, though. Like colorful ponies would be bad for Felarya and giant nagas would be bad for Equestria.

I imagine someone could draw what they think MLP's would look like in centaur form.

Grave wrote:

I imagine someone could draw what they think MLP's would look like in centaur form.

Don't give wizards ideas man.

Ponis are al over the internet, not just here, don't like them then just ignore them, or join the herd lol.

Well, some say no some say yes. But, if you have the right idea, ponies could end up eating people! Which would be kind of weird to see... Anyway, AzureJass is completely right! ^.^ Ignore or JOIN THE HERD (Join the herd.. it's worth it)! Going back to the main idea... I wouldn't think that you would get eaten.... I think you would get killed by being squashed under a hoof Ouch...

(Fist of all, hi again)

Ponies are awesome, yes. And I suppose in the right hands, it would make a decent fanfiction.

But then, the writer would need to pick a theme. The high, dangerous adventure of Felarya, or the happy friendship of Ponies?

It kind of like it would be with, say, Phineas and Ferb. If it follows the cartoon's formula or tone, it'd be a crazy good read. If it's the Felaryan feel, it'd be horrifying.

But crossovers don't generally work that well, especially in massively structured worlds like Felarya. Baaad idea.

Its like this.

People, there exists a My Little Pony FiM/Silent Hill crossover. Let that sink in for a moment. A colorful, cotton-candy feel-good toon like My Little Pony merged with the single-most depraved, psychologically-taxing video game series is existence. If that was doable, then I'm sorry, I cannot see how a crossover with the brutal yet sometimes humorous (Crisis + Anna = comedy gold) world of Felarya is impossible.

And I'll toot my own for a moment to say I've made disparate elements work. Like combining Harry Potter and Metroid. Twice. And making plans to complete a trilogy. These sort of things aren't impossible if effort is involved.

I know my deal with crossovers, as well. I'm currently making a Spanish webcomic which is just a badfic, crossover fest. And I know how to mix things good and bad... Sure, you can, for example, have Lobo and Deadpool fighting each other (without Marvel's filthy trick of Dirty Wolff as their own Lobo replacement), but you can also put... don't know... Yukari from the Touhou games? And do it BAD. Though people won't tell me, they just find it weird. Specially when they find a lovable Pyramid Head. xD

Anyway, crossovers are possible and I haven't read any of this MLP/SH crossover, yet I know it exists. But didn't dare to read it: I can't imagine Fluttershy trying to run away from Pyramid Head, for example. I just can't - mainly because Fluttershy is the cutest thing ever and Pyramid Head is a depraved monster... and this is going by canon PH, not things my light-hearted, lovable Pymie. Because the MPL/SH mix feels so forced, so out of place... Anyway, that's me, better don't listen to the looney guy who is making his own illustrated badfic who made the PH a cute robot's boyfriend. xD

Speak for yourself. The bizarre dichotomy is what makes me want to read Silent Ponyville in the first place, and the challenge of outlandish crossover is what's leading me into trying a Felarya crossover with something that...has no supernatural elements whatsoever.

I'll speak for myself then: I have my experience with crossovers, I'm just giving my impression on the matter, sorry if that wasn't your cup of tea. xD (In all seriousness, really, I was giving my opinion and my opinion is that some things just don't mix... exceptions exist, though, and it depends more on the author of the crossover than on the franchises that got in)