There are two things we do unwillingly in real life, but are unavoidable: Rumors, and dumbness. We already got the rumors going, but I think Felarya had its share of stupidity too. I got this idea after reading GameSpy's 25 dumbest moments in gaming, if you hadn't read it, go read it. I warn you, read the number 1 last.
So basically, just like rumors, think of dumb or awkward situations Felarya had its share of. Try to avoid little embarassement that affects only one person. Try to think of dumb decision or movements that, if it was averted, would have changed the future, in a way. Like, if Ur-Sagol hadn't be so expantionist, it would still be here today. It doesn't need to have such an impact, but it needs to have an impact nonetheless.