General Q and A

itsmeyouidiot wrote:

Well, I don't know about you, but not getting the crap kicked out of me would be a pretty good incentive for me to not do something.

Trouble it, when it comes to pure physical power, stamina, and experience out in the wild, Jade and Crisis seem pretty even. That's why I get the feeling there's a bit more to it.

Crisis is friendly and reasonable. She doesn't like violence and purposefully tries to avoid fight, going as far as stalling as much as possible even if she already knows a fight will break out sooner or later. She would know that Jade will gladly fight with any giant just to keep them away from the village, and I don't know if the two befriended each other beforehand, but Crisis is well aware that attacking the village would only result in trouble. Long story short, Crisis is not dumb.

I read somewhere that a section of Negav has a anti-warping magic or something to protect if from dimensional shift. I'd like to know how difficult is this magic to learn/ use?

Difficult enough that a newbie trying it would explode. Oh so gloriously.

hello everyone.

how does "Sulfur sources" (in Great Rocky Fields) looks like? Any special hints? Inhabitants? Plants? The size of zone itself?

Sean Okotami wrote:

Difficult enough that a newbie trying it would explode. Oh so gloriously.

XD Thanks for both the infromation AND the image!

I'd just like to know, why is it called "Tolmeshal Forest" or the "central forest" if it's a jungle?

Actually it's more like a Rainforest.
The word jungle is taken from the Hindi language, and is generally associated with extremely dense, nearly impassable vegetation they have there, which doesn't seem to be the case for Tolmeshal. (Though there might be patches of 'jungle' here and there within it)

While thinking about makign a Nemesis character for a party I wondered something about their hunting rules. Can a Nemesis eat regular food? Or does she eat other dreamers in the Dreamscape? I'm talking just regularly when she's not marked somebody.

They possess the ability to consume apples.

question about fairies

Can a fairy, while being in human size, pick up a granade and enlarge him\herself WITH grenade to the giant size? Will that granade remain to be giant sized (and thus contain giant explosive power) if fairy throw it to somewhere? Can a fairy use a firearm in same way?

and btw, how much energy a fairy uses in order to make him\herself tiny or giant?

I believe they would be able to enlarge/shrink the grenade even without touching it. That's how I understand Fairy magic, anyway. I doubt it would take TOO much energy to shrink/grow. It's their specialty, and they use it often enough that it seems to take the same energy as breathing would. Okay, that was exaggerating a little. But it's probably a barely noticeable amount of energy used.

I'm kinda nervous why a Fairy would need giant grenades or firearms...

Boris92 wrote:

I'm kinda nervous why a Fairy would need giant grenades or firearms...

well, I was writing a story about one curious little fairy who likes to peeking at humans. The little winged thing got her mind blown when she discovered how does firearms work, and what grenades can do. Soon she stole some grenades and one combat riffle from one sleeping adventurer for herself and...

and This is the point where I need the answer. Surely, she'll run out of ammo pretty soon, but atleast she can have some fun while she has few clips and grenades, can't she?))

It was my understanding that energy/power/force isn't relative to the size of the source so a grenade's explosive power would not change. I could be wrong though

Rezec wrote:

and btw, how much energy a fairy uses in order to make him\herself tiny or giant?

My understanding is that the answer is "a lot"
Fairy wings are specialized magic capacitor/collectors that enable them to channel energy required to cast their size changing spells. The fact that such organs are required implies that a lot of magic power is used.
The question is whether or not the energy that is added to the grenade to make it giant contributes to the explosion.


Rezec, your question is very pertinent to how size changing magic works (and I believe that this is why we should work out HOW it works, since it would questions like this.)

There is no canon answer currently.

Anime-Junkie wrote:

There is no canon answer currently.

so... can I take it as "Possible yes, but fairy have to put a lot of magic energy into grenade in order to blow up something huge", right? Same with firearms, I presume.

thanks for answer, AJ!))

HeavenlessStar wrote:

It was my understanding that energy/power/force isn't relative to the size of the source so a grenade's explosive power would not change. I could be wrong though

Yes and no. The grenade's explosive power would remain the same. What would change is its scale. It is still the same grenade, just scaled up. To a fairy, it would explode the same no matter what size she chose to be with it. To a human, the explosion, shrapnel and so on would be considerably larger though.

It's like how magic works with a fairy. If she's making a fireball, the fireball is still exactly the same the whole time. What changes is the scale, and how it is perceived by people of different sizes as the scale changes. That is the big drawback to size-changing magic. You are only as strong as your scale. A fairy's magical power and spells never change, only the scale of them.

Ok, I'm lost as usual. xD

This reminds me of why I consider giant sized mages more powerful than human sized mages. Power is relative to scale, right?

I'd comment that it's not the case, but that would spark Magic Debate #518, so all I'm going to say is, depends on the type of magic and caster's experience.

I don't really wanna go there either but I'm tempted. It's hard to not think a human put up against a giant mage of the skill level wouldn't find him/her self overwhelmed.

Well, you just answered your own question, skill level. Humans have the advantage of easily accessible knowledge, which is paramount for a good mage, except for wild magic, innate magic, and possibly ley lines magic. Giants, with the exception of fairies, don't usually have access to tomes that will teach them new spells, so most of the time, their magic is either only rudimentary, or is inherent to their species.

HeavenlessStar wrote:

Ok, I'm lost as usual. xD

This reminds me of why I consider giant sized mages more powerful than human sized mages. Power is relative to scale, right?

That.... is complicated.

More "powerful" in terms of raw magic used, but not necessarily in relative effect. Let me try to explain this in an (hopefully) understandable manner.

1: A 6ft tall human creates a baseball-sized fireball.

2: A 110ft tall naga creates a baseball-sized fireball relative to her.

Both mages are expending the same effort to create what is basically the same fireball. Both are exerting basically the same amount of effort and using (relative to their scale) the same amount of magical energy. Technically the naga is using more magical energy because she is larger and is making a larger fireball, but it takes the same amount of effort as the human is using to make his.

Basically, what I'm trying to say is that, being bigger doesn't make it easier to use magic. Just because your body can harness more magical energy doesn't mean that your magic is inherently better. The requirements scale up along with the effects.

My own theory is that, as you scale up, manipulating smaller-scale magic also becomes more and more difficult. Like, trying to use tweezers to manipulate a tiny gun. For example, in my interpretation, a naga wouldn't even be able to form a human-scale version of her fireball. It would be too small, and too delicate for her to form and manipulate with her magic. Just my own take on it of course, but I like it.

It was comprehensible. C:

Keep in mind, however, that magic is still a thing of debate on here. Very, very strong debate.

To continue Cliff's example, some would argue that a Giant Predator who can make a to scale baseball sized fireball is one of exceptional talent, as the scale of the caster doesn't matter. In D&D, for example, the Level 3 "Fireball" spell is the exact same size whether you're a Pixie, a Human, or a Titan, but for all three it remains a spell that only a Level 6 Sorcerer / Wizard could cast. In this case, it's less someone drawing magic through themselves / from their body, and more manipulating some sort of ever-present force (akin to the Weave, or Winds of Chaos).

At the same time, there's those argue that magic comes from the casters themselves. In these cases, by all means a Giant Predator should have spells scaled up in size / potency, as they're drawing from a volume several dozen / hundred times that of the average person. Magical energy that could explode a human trying to funnel it can be safely coursed through the Giant Predator.

And, overall, neither of these are either right or wrong. If you wanted to make a story wherein the average Giant Predator "Wizard" cannot lob fireballs the size of a double decker bus, you can do that. If you want to make a story where a Giant Predator "Wizard" lobs said-sized fireball, and it was about as troublesome to them as a medium-sized fireball to a human wizard, that's similarly fine. You should try to respect the magical limits defined for pre-existing characters (ex: If Vivian is said to be able to do [y], she can still do [y]), but otherwise you're allowed to go nuts.